Wit and vision at the grave of Mandela’s lawyer


Who will replace people like this? Advocate and friend of Mandela, Jules Browde, was of a breed of men shaped by the major events of the twentieth century

IN South Africa’s current political climate, dominated by corrupt politicians’ bluster, unseemly scuffles in Parliament and mobs burning schools and artworks, among other things, it is refreshing to find spots of quietness and integrity behind the public din.

A funeral of a 98-year old man might seem an unlikely place, but such was last Sunday’s event at West Park Cemetery in Johannesburg of advocate, activist and Jewish leader Jules Browde, infused with his optimistic wordview and enduring sense of humour. Sad as a good man’s passing is, the feeling was of a life well lived.

The warm friendship during apartheid’s early years between Browde and Oliver Tambo and Nelson Mandela was the start of a long, meaningful relationship. This took place before Tambo’s exile from the country to lead the ANC, and Mandela’s imprisonment for 27 years which interrupted the friendship – it resumed after his release in 1990.

Browde and Mandela had studied law together, and in the 1950s he was the legal counsel for Tambo in his application for admission as an attorney, despite the racial laws. Later, he acted for the legal practice of Mandela and Tambo – successfully – when the apartheid government attempted to evict them from their offices because they were in “white” Johannesburg.

“Today everyone likes to say they knew Mandela, but at that time, to be a friend of Mandela was not popular in white society,” said the rabbi to the mourners who included constitutional court judges, legal figures, artists, activists, and leaders of the left-wing Zionist youth movement Habonim – he was its national president for 25 years.

The brutal application of racial laws by the apartheid regime, including imprisonment without trial, torture, evictions and other means, led Browde and other jurists to establish Lawyers for Human Rights in 1980, which publicised human rights abuses and confronted them through litigation. He was its chairman during the State of Emergency in the mid-80s. After democracy, President Mandela appointed him to investigate irregularities in the appointment of public officials.

A notable figure at the funeral was Johannesburg’s mayor Parks Tau – a member of the ANC ruling party – with an honour guard of black men and women in city uniforms to accompany the coffin to the grave. The rabbi noted with a smile that officially, Browde was still a city employee, evoking a warm nod from Tau. He did not believe in retirement, and still had several months to complete his contract.

Touching obliquely on the corruption issue – the hottest topic in public discourse today – Tau stressed the importance he placed on probity among city officials and Browde’s role in its integrity committee, in which he engaged with over 200 councillors to ensure their financial affairs complied with transparency regulations.

The city had offered him his first five-year contract when he was in his late 80s, despite his wry, humorous warning that because of his age he might not be there to complete it. But he saw it through, and was offered additional five-year contracts.

In a moving scene after completion of the formal Jewish ceremony, the city guard took up shovels and filled the grave with earth – a rare glimpse into a potential South Africa where colour didn’t matter.

The serenity of a worthy life completed, with no need of fanfare. There were no political speeches, cries of “Amandla!” or earnest political party representatives with the red overalls of the  EFF, the blue T-shirts of the DA, the red, green and black symbols of the ANC, or others. No jostling for prominence.

Several women participated in shovelling earth onto his coffin during the ceremony. Although contrary to the Orthodox Jewish community’s custom of calling only on men to do this, it seemed entirely natural – and the rabbis did not stir. And when it came to the family saying kaddish at the end, his wife of 68 years, Selma, also participated with her sons. Again, this seemed entirely natural, though it was not the usual custom for women to do it. But for Browde, no-one would be excluded.

The generation of Jewish men who were born in the early part of the twentieth century – like Browde – were moulded by major events such as the Second World War against Hitler in which he fought for five and a half years in the South African artillery; the flourishing and expansion of South African Jewry; life under apartheid and the choice of whether and how to resist it; and the idealism for building a new, humane state of Israel in the aftermath of the Holocaust. Some of them, like Browde, became allies of giants like Mandela and Tambo.

This year marks the twentieth anniversary of the beginning of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission under the chairmanship of Archbishop Desmond Tutu, which was intended to heal wounds of apartheid by giving victims and perpetrators of atrocities the chance to face each other and tell their stories.

But reconciliation has fallen far short of its goal. The country stands at a dangerous crossroad – will it continue descending into violence, corruption and cynicism, or regain the idealism of Mandela’s rainbow nation?

Most of Browde’s peers – the visionaries and activists – have passed on. Who will replace them to help this confused, increasingly cynical country find its way?

(Geoff Sifrin is a journalist based in Johannesburg, South Africa, and former Editor of the SA Jewish Report. Email: geoffs@icon.co.za)

3 thoughts on “Wit and vision at the grave of Mandela’s lawyer

  1. Upon returning home from my year at the Machon, my plans to study at Wits were delayed when a very impatient (to get to Jerusalem) Giddy Shimoni persuaded me to take on the role of “General Secretary” of Habonim. I became the CEO of the movement and found myself reporting to and working hand in hand with Jules the Chairman of the Board (the Hanagah).
    I am not sure I realized it then but from my present position with hindsight I can say it was one of the most incredible learning experiences ever.
    Jules was the most brilliant analyst and could cut through all the mountains of ideological verbiage and sum up a meeting in a way everyone was satisfied.!! I am talking about a period where there were massive differences between the groups kibbutz vs. town; SA vs. Israeli ; religious issues; etc. He always kept his cool, his great sense of humor and above all an incredible sense of intimacy and friendship.
    And now I learn that all this time he had another life, another commitment to the ANC and their struggle. We had no idea! Indeed we often wondered why he never set an example and go on Aliya!!! What can I say the description of his funeral which appears to have been dominated by his “other side” says it all.
    When I think about it I feel that for him and the values he cherished he did the right thing. Keeping so secret was very much in character and shows an amazing sense of priorities which were his own and were followed through till the very end!
    What a privilege it was to work side by side with this modest giant of a man who made a difference in both his committed goals.


  2. Hi Colin,
    A name from the distant past. I reckon that our paths last crossed some 58 years ago at some Habonim venue when we were still young and handsome, determined to solve all the problems in the world. I have lived in Israel since 1970 after serving as a volunteer in the Israeli Army in 1959, after my matriculation. I returned to Israel, again as a volunteer, to rejoin my unit for the 6 – Day War in 1967.
    I look forward to your kind reply.
    Lennie Lurie.


    • Hi Lenny,
      Good to hear from you. Have often wondered what became of you after we made contact way back in Cape Town when we were both in “the movement”
      I always saw you as one of those “heady & bright” Cape Townians” the likes of the late Lazer Choritz, Shalom Zausmer, Woolfie M and my current friend and golf companion Rafi Shelef
      Where are you these days??
      I have been to Cape Town twice this last year and back again for a roots trip with my Grandson!!
      Would like to hear from you and catch up


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s